Simply Amish Relocates to Castle Key Shoppes
Simply Amish Relocates to Castle Key Shoppes
Apr 3 • Written by Jen Hallgarth
Simply Amish, known for its handcrafted, solid-wood furniture, has relocated to a new appx 10,000 square foot upscale storefront at Castle Key Shoppes at the Clearwater Trade Area on 82nd/86th Street in Indianapolis.
The move marks a strategic shift from the brand’s longtime location at 5612 Castleton Corner Lane in Castleton to the North of Castleton Square Mall, where it operated since 2008. That former space—once home to a Borders bookstore—served the retailer for over 15 years.
The new store, located at 4505 E. 82nd Street, occupies the former flooring showroom and is already open to customers. A grand opening event was held on February 10.
Simply Amish’s new home sits in a highly visible corridor near the major retailer regional trade areas of Keystone at The Crossing and Castleton Square Mall, which includes dense residential neighborhoods. The updated space offers better access, improved visibility, and proximity to complementary home goods stores.
Founded in South Central Illinois in 1979, Simply Amish sources its furniture from American craftsmen and emphasizes custom design, long-lasting materials, and timeless style.
“We’re proud to help bring Simply Amish into a space that better fits their brand and position within the largest furniture retail trade area in Indiana. They’re a great example of a retailer that puts quality first, and we’re excited to support their continued success in this market.”
DeMao Retail played a key role in securing the relocation and ensuring a seamless transition within the 86th/82nd Street trade area—one of the most active retail zones in Indianapolis.
This move strengthens Simply Amish’s footprint in the trade area while aligning with DeMao Retail’s mission to support long-term value for tenants and property owners in core commercial corridors.
Interested in National / Regional Tenant Representation Services? Contact DeMao Retail at (317) 683-0420 or tenant@demaoretail.com.
For media inquiries or to feature this story, reach out to our PR team at media@demaoretail.com
In the News
West Elm, Simply Amish stores on the move along north-side corridor
Dave Lindquist, Indiana Business Journal